01

A hotel the carrier said was owed nothing

National-brand hotel Hurricane

The carrier's first answer was that the hurricane damage would not even reach the deductible: zero dollars owed. We documented the loss and rebuilt the claim from the evidence. The same carrier settled it at $500,000 before the deductible.

Carrier's first position
$0
Below the deductible — nothing owed.
What the claim settled at
$500,000
Settled — before the deductible is applied.
From nothing owed +$500,000 above where the carrier started
02

Estimated at $525. Below the deductible. Nothing owed.

Single-family residence Storm damage Allstate

Allstate wrote the loss up at $525. Because that sat under the policy deductible, the carrier owed nothing at all — the claim was effectively closed on a number smaller than most people's monthly premium. Documented for what the damage actually was, the same claim settled at $51,405.42.

Carrier's first position
$0
Their estimate came to $525 — under the deductible, so nothing was payable.
What the claim settled at
$51,405.42
Final settlement on the claim.
From nothing owed +$51,405.42 above where the carrier started
03

Six thousand five hundred, against a six-figure loss

Single-family residence State Farm

The carrier opened at $6,535.78 — precise to the penny, and nowhere close to the loss. Once the damage was documented and the claim rebuilt on evidence, the same insurer paid $112,000.

Carrier's first offer
$6,535.78
The insurer's opening number, to the penny.
What the claim settled at
$112,000
Final settlement on the claim.
17× the first offer +$105,464.22 above where the carrier started
04

Already approved — at nine hundred and forty-four dollars

Allstate

Allstate approved the claim at $944.82. Approved — evaluated, accepted, and priced. Re-documented and rebuilt on evidence, the same claim closed at $41,515.01: forty-four times the figure the carrier had already signed off on.

Carrier's approved amount
$944.82
Not a denial — the insurer approved the claim at this figure.
What the claim settled at
$41,515.01
Final settlement on the claim.
44× the amount Allstate approved +$40,570.19 above where the carrier started
05

Below the deductible. Then eighty-seven thousand.

State Farm

State Farm's position was that the loss fell below the deductible: no payment owed. The damage was documented and the claim rebuilt on evidence, and the same carrier settled it at $87,147.41.

Carrier's first position
$0
Below the deductible — nothing owed.
What the claim settled at
$87,147.41
Final settlement on the claim.
From nothing owed +$87,147.41 above where the carrier started
06

Nothing owed — on a six-figure loss

Allstate

Allstate's position was that the damage fell below the deductible: nothing owed. Documented and rebuilt on evidence, the same claim settled at $127,975.10 — a six-figure loss the carrier had valued at zero.

Carrier's first position
$0
Below the deductible — nothing owed.
What the claim settled at
$127,975.10
Final settlement on the claim.
From nothing owed +$127,975.10 above where the carrier started
07

A hurricane loss priced at fourteen thousand

Hurricane Allstate

Allstate opened at $14,399 on a hurricane loss. Documented and rebuilt on evidence, the claim was approved at $150,000 before deductible and policy limits — better than ten times where the carrier started.

Carrier's first offer
$14,399
The insurer's opening number on a hurricane loss.
What the claim settled at
$150,000
Approved — before deductible and policy limits.
10× the first offer +$135,601 above where the carrier started
08

A six-figure offer that was still $170,000 short

USAA

Not every underpayment looks like an insult. USAA valued this loss at $198,992.15 — a substantial offer, and one most policyholders would have signed. Rebuilt on documented evidence, the same claim settled at $369,746.78: another $170,754.63 the carrier's own number had missed.

Carrier's first offer
$198,992.15
A serious six-figure number — the kind most policyholders accept.
What the claim settled at
$369,746.78
Final settlement on the claim.
+86% above the first offer +$170,754.63 above where the carrier started
09

Valued under a $5,000 deductible. Settled at $139,320.93.

Allstate

Allstate's position was that the damage did not reach the $5,000 deductible: nothing owed. Documented and rebuilt on evidence, the same claim settled at $139,320.93 — nearly twenty-eight times the deductible the carrier had hidden behind.

Carrier's first position
$0
Below the $5,000 deductible — nothing owed.
What the claim settled at
$139,320.93
Final settlement on the claim.
From nothing owed +$139,320.93 above where the carrier started
10

A fire loss the carrier had already paid

Fire Esurance

Esurance did not deny this fire claim. It paid it — $237,726.78, issued, file closed. Reopened and rebuilt on documented evidence, the same loss settled at $543,817.71: another $306,090.93 on a claim the carrier had already considered finished.

Carrier's initial payment
$237,726.78
Not a denial — paid, and the file closed.
What the claim settled at
$543,817.71
Final settlement on the claim.
+129% above the amount already paid +$306,090.93 above where the carrier started

Every figure on this page is taken from the settled claim file, and every settlement figure is stated gross — before the policy deductible is applied. Past recoveries describe what happened on those claims and are not a prediction about yours; every policy and every loss is different.

25% Your path to representedTap to continue your case review
Call now Free Case Review